Christmas Star Sugar Cookies

Christmas Star Cookies

I’m really proud of myself right now! I made my first batch of decorated sugar cookies with royal icing. They’re not perfect but they look pretty good and they tasted great!

Christmas Star Cookies

If you read this blog on a regular basis than you’ll know that I’m terrible at decorating. I blame my unsteady hands. When I was invited to a cookie decorating class I was worried I wouldn’t be able to do it. I’d never actually attempted anything with royal icing before. It would be a miracle if they could teach me anything!

Christmas Star Cookies

The teacher was great and luckily I did learn a few things. It takes a lot of practice to get great looking cookies so to start with I decided on one shape and only simple decorations, glitter and sanding sugar. The stars could be Christmas or would also be good for Hanukkah. The cookies with glitter look way more impressive in person. The camera doesn’t capture it well.

Christmas Star Cookies

I’ve been reading cookie blogs for a few years now (I like looking at the pretty pictures). They are amazing and are a great source of tips and information.

I used the sugar cookie recipe from Bake at 350 (without the almond) and I used a box of Tate & Lyle royal icing (it was enough to frost about 40 cookies). I made the cookie dough on Thursday night, rolled out the dough on Friday, baked the cookies on Saturday morning and decorated them on Saturday afternoon.

I mixed the whole box of royal icing and tinted it yellow. I made it fairly stiff so I could pipe the perimeter of the star first. While those dried I added a little more water to the icing and poured it into a squeezy bottle. I filled the cookies and used a toothpick to spread the icing to the small points of the star. While it was still wet I sprinkled on the glitter and the sanding sugar. I let the cookies dry overnight.

Got Milk Magic Straws are also awesome.

I was invited to attend the Christmas biscuit icing class at I Made it Myself

You Might Like:


  1. They look great! Good enough to eat! ;0)
    I bought a decorating kit and a handful of cookie cutters… Just haven’t had the confidence and/or time to try it out!

  2. These look great – you did a far better job than I could! I always rely on bought-in decorations!

  3. They look super! It’s just like colouring in with crayons once you get the hang of it. A bit of experience seeing how the icing behaves at different consistencies, holding the piping bag right way, using the right nozzles and you’re 80% of the way there.

    Are you going to do any more?

    • Icing 50 Christmas cookies is about my limit! I’m definitely going to make some more for Valentine’s Day though.